Grading the best A&A tools.
eMASS, Xacta, ServiceNow IRM, RegScale, and the spreadsheets that still run half the government. Graded on evidence automation, usability, and readiness for continuous authorization.
Every assessment-and-authorization shop lives inside one of a handful of tools. These are our grades from the practitioner seat. Criteria: evidence automation, usability for the people doing the work, ecosystem fit, and where it's headed as continuous authorization becomes the expectation.
The report card
| Tool | Grade | The one-line truth |
|---|---|---|
| eMASS | C+ | Mandatory where it's mandatory; it runs the certification workflow but adds little security |
| Xacta | B | IC heritage and depth, enterprise weight to match |
| ServiceNow IRM/GRC | B+ | The strongest workflow and evidence automation of the group; strongest when A&A meets operations |
| RegScale | B+ | Compliance-as-code and OSCAL-native, a fit for where authorization is heading |
| Spreadsheets & SharePoint | D | The most widely deployed A&A platform in government, unfortunately |
eMASS: C+
The system of record for much of DoD, and unavoidable there. It tracks controls, POA&Ms, and artifacts competently, and assessors know it cold. But it works like a filing cabinet: evidence goes in by hand, automation hooks are limited, and it makes your package more legible without making your system more secure. Grade reflects the gap between market position and capability. (Our full eMASS vs Xacta comparison goes deeper.)
Xacta: B
The intelligence community's workhorse, with real strengths in inheritance modeling and multi-tenant enterprise deployments. Deep, configurable, and correspondingly heavy: Xacta programs need Xacta people. Where it's installed and staffed, it performs.
ServiceNow IRM: B+
Not an A&A system of record in the eMASS sense, and that is its advantage. Continuous control monitoring, evidence collection wired to live operational data, and workflow automation that measurably reduces analyst hours. Strongest play: run authorization operations on IRM while the mandated system of record stays the compliance facade. That's the architecture we implement most, and it's where the ROI shows up.
RegScale: B+
The most forward-leaning of the group: OSCAL-native, API-first, compliance-as-code philosophy that treats the SSP as a living data object instead of a Word document. Fewer integrations and a smaller installed base than the incumbents, which is the cost of buying early. It matters more as CSRMC-style continuous authorization becomes policy (our CSRMC explainer).
Spreadsheets: D
Still the true market leader by deployment count. Zero license cost, infinite flexibility, and catastrophic at scale: no inheritance, no automation, no audit trail, and a single-analyst bus factor. If this is your platform, any move up this report card pays for itself in the first assessment cycle.
The point
An ATO rests on evidence, whichever tool holds it. The grade that matters is whether your evidence regenerates itself from pipelines and telemetry or gets retyped every cycle. Pick the tool that automates the most evidence for your stack, and remember the tool is maybe 30% of the outcome; the operating discipline around it is the rest.
Quick answers
Do we get a choice of A&A tool?
Is OSCAL worth caring about yet?
What should a small shop start with?
Related reading
Working on this now?
Tell us where your program stands and we'll tell you what we would do next.
Talk to Ausper